Bromford Housing Association Ltd v Lasharna Robinson [2026] EWCC 61

County Court (Birmingham)

14 October 2026

The County Court has held that where an injunction is granted requiring a tenant to permit access to a landlord to conduct an electrical safety inspection, it is able to make a “rolled up” order permitting forced entry if the tenant refuses to comply with the injunction.

Under The Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) Regulations 2020, landlords are obliged to inspect electrical installations in their tenants’ properties at intervals of no longer than five years.

The Landlord (“Bromford Housing Association”) had last carried out an electrical safety inspection of the Tenant’s (“Ms Robinson”) property five years ago, on 2nd September 2021. Clause 3.30 of the tenancy agreement required Ms Robinson to allow Bromford Housing Association on 48 hours' notice to inspect the condition of the property and carry out its legal obligations.

On 26 June 2026, Bromford Housing Association informed Ms Robinson by letter that it intended to carry out an electrical inspection on 29 June 2026. However, Ms Robinson rejected multiple attempts by engineers to gain access to her property and did not respond to various follow-up emails, text messages and telephone messages. When Ms Robinson eventually responded on 28 July 2026, she said that she had recently had surgery and that she was unable to clear away items in the cupboard which gave access to the electrical consumer unit. Further attempts by Bromford Housing Association to obtain a suitable appointment date and attempts by engineers to access the property were both refused. The involvement of “Neighbourhood Coaches” was also unsuccessful.

Consequently, Bromford Housing Association applied for (1) an injunction requiring Ms Robinson to allow access to the property to carry out the electrical safety inspection; and (2) an order permitting forcible entry if access to the property was refused.

The County Court, in allowing the application, held that Bromford Housing Association had a contractual right that obliged Ms Robinson to grant access to the property. The contractual duty in clause.3.30 to allow inspection of “the condition” of the property was broad enough to cover an electrical inspection. In addition, section 11(6) of TheLandlord and Tenant Act 1985 implied a tenant's covenant to allow the landlord entry on notice to view the property's condition and state of repair. As both of those causes of action were made out, the balance of convenience favoured granting an injunction. The Court also held that where a mandatory injunction had been granted, it had the power to make a “rolled up” order permitting forced entry if the tenant refused to comply with the injunction. It deemed this appropriate in situations such as this one, where the tenant's history of non-compliance indicated that a mandatory access order would be ignored (resulting in the case having to come back to court for a further hearing, with further expenditure of costs)

The decision will be welcomed by social housing providers, as it shows that, in certain circumstances, the courts are willing to grant “rolled-up” orders where the tenant has a recorded history of persistent non-compliance with access requests.

A copy of the judgment is here.

Salford City Council v Brown [2026] UKUT 393 (LC).

Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)

19 October 2026

The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) has held that the delegation of responsibility for HMO compliance by a director to a non-director does not rule out that director’s liability for non-compliance.

Mr Brown was the sole director of a number of related companies which are in the business of managing rented properties on behalf of landlords.

Mr Brown was a sole director of one of these companies, Want This Room Limited. This company managed the property 151 Manchester Road, Worsley, Manchester, which operated as a House in Multiple Occupation (“HMO”). In February 2023, Salford City Council imposed a financial penalty on Mr Brown (after following the correct process of notices under the Housing Act 2004) of £10,850 on the basis that Want This Room Limited had failed to comply with HMO regulations and that Mr Brown was therefore liable under section 251 of TheHousing Act 2004. Mr Brown appealed to the First-tier Tribunal.

The First-tier Tribunal, in allowing the appeal, found that Mr Brown, the sole director of Want This Room Limited, had not “exercised any neglect” because responsibility for housing compliance and the day-to-day management of Want This Room Limited had been delegated to shadow director Ms Kemi Egan and her team. Mr Brown had a considerable portfolio of properties across many companies and he was therefore entitled to rely on Ms Egan's expertise to manage the property and for her to ensure that the company complied with housing legislation. He was not under a duty to supervise the running of Want This Room Limited and it was proper for him to leave the running of the company to her. Salford City Council appealed.

The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), in allowing the appeal, held that the First-tier Tribunal was wrong, finding that:

  1.  The delegation of responsibility for statutory compliance with housing legislation and regulation to a person who is not a director cannot, by itself, preclude liability under section 251 of The Housing Act 2004. whereas a division of responsibilities between directors may do so.
  2. The fact that a director has “overstretched himself” across several companies does not remove his statutory liabilities.

Salford City Council secured a fresh hearing, as the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) remitted the matter to a differently constituted First-tier Tribunal, which must determine afresh whether (1) Want This Room Limited had committed an offence, and, if so, whether (2) that offence was attributable to neglect on Mr Brown's part, applying the criminal standard of proof.

A copy of the judgment is here.