Clock is ticking: High Court addresses when the time limit for a procurement challenge commences under the Procurement Act 2023
17/11/26On 3 November 2026, the High Court handed down a judgment addressing when the statutory time limit to bring a procurement challenge commences under the Procurement Act 2023 (the Act).
In Verity Healthcare Ltd (Claimant) v Cambridgeshire County Council (Defendant) [2026] EWHC 2830 (TCC), the Judge granted a summary judgment relating to the Claimant’s challenge. This challenge concerned a condition of participation requiring suppliers to hold a Care Quality Commission (CQC) rating of ‘Good’ or above. The Claimant argued this condition of participation was disproportionate. The summary judgment was granted in favour of the Defendant on the basis that the Claimant had not commenced proceedings within 30 days of the date on which it first knew or ought to have known about the circumstances giving rise to the claim.
The Court said the Claimant ought to have had knowledge of the condition of participation on the date of publication of the tender notice and tender documents containing the relevant condition. The Court further confirmed that it is not incumbent on a commissioning body to inform suppliers of the procurement portal it intends to use, even if they are incumbent providers. As the evidence in this case makes clear, obtaining notifications or alerts from Find a Tender or Google is what suppliers should do and do do.
The summary judgment provides a helpful reminder of when the clock will start ticking for a procurement challenge and the need for suppliers to actively monitor and consider tender opportunities to determine if they have grounds for challenge.
The background
The claim arose during a procurement undertaken by the Defendant to establish a Homecare Framework through which regulated homecare services would be provided to adults across Cambridgeshire for a term of up to 10 years (the Procurement). The total value of the Homecare Framework is estimated to be £928,080,000 (including VAT). The Procurement is being conducted as a competitive flexible procedure under the Act.
The Defendant required that the supplier must hold a CQC rating of ‘Good’ or above, and the Claimant was registered with the CQC but it did not meet this CQC rating condition set by the Defendant.
The Claimant’s grounds for bringing the claim was that the introduction of the CQC rating condition was not proportionate and therefore was in breach of Section 22 of the Act.
The Claimant issued a claim form and Particulars of Claim, along with an application for interim relief, on 17 August 2026. On 21 August 2026, the Defendant issued an application to strike out the claim and/or for a summary judgment on the grounds that the claim had not been commenced within the statutory time limit as set out in Section 106 of the Act.
Section 106(2) of the Act states: “A supplier must commence any other proceedings under this Part before the end of the period of 30 days beginning with the day on which the supplier first knew, or ought to have known, about the circumstances giving rise to the claim.”
The Claimant claimed it first became aware of the live Procurement and CQC rating conditions on 19 July 2026 and argued that this was the date on which the condition became, from the Claimant’s perspective, an actual and immediate barrier to participation.
The Defendant’s counter argument to this was that the Claimant had actual or constructive knowledge of the Procurement earlier than 19 July 2026, and therefore the claim had not been issued within the 30-day limit required by Section 106(2) of the Act.
The Claimant argued that the delay arose because it had not been aware that the Defendant was conducting this opportunity through a new portal, rather than through the portal the Defendant had previously used.
The Defendant's argument remained that the statutory time limit commenced from the date of tender publication – 15 July 2026 – meaning the claim was out of time, as it was issued on 17 August 2026.
The judgment
The Court found that the claim was out of time.
In considering “constructive knowledge” under section 106 of the Act, the Judge found no reason why the test should differ from the reasonably well-informed and normally diligent tenderer test (the RWIND test) applied under the Public Contracts Regulations 2015.
Applying the RWIND test, the Judge accepted the Defendant’s submission that the Claimant ought to have had knowledge of the relevant circumstances – the procurement and the condition of participation – on the date of publication (15 July 2026), and therefore because the Claimant issued the claim on 17 August 2026, this meant the claim was out of time.
The Judge went on to say that the Claimant could have become aware of the Procurement by registering for notifications and could then immediately and reasonably have become aware of the conditions in the tender documents to which the relevant link was given.
How Capsticks can help
Our Procurement team acts for both contracting authorities and bidders, which means we always advise in the context of understanding both perspectives. The team has extensive experience advising across all aspects of public procurement, from structuring a procurement process, options appraisals, implementation and conduct of procurement processes, to defending and bringing procurement challenges for contracting authorities and bidders.
If you are interested in how we may be able to support your organisation in light of this judgment, please contact Head of Public Procurement Mary Mundy, Procurement Litigation Partner Tim Dennis or Principal Associate Anjli Vyas.








