News

The Foundation Trust Estate

We have been working with our foundation trust clients to help manage their estates more effectively.

It is essential for a ...

Read more

Clinical Excellence Awards 2012

The Clinical Excellence Awards exist to recognise consultants (and academic GPs) who are able to demonstrate excellence in their work for the NHS. On an annual basis consultants may submit an application to be considered for a Clinical Excellence ...

Read more

Court of Appeal upholds National Paediatric Cardiac Consultation

The Court of Appeal has reversed the original decision quashing the consultation made in judicial review proceedings brought by the Royal Brompton & Harefield Foundation Trust (RBHFT) in the first ever legal challenge brought by one NHS body a...

Read more

Squatting – a criminal offence?

Viewed by some as 'the vulnerable homeless' and by others in a less charitable light, squatters enter and remain in occupation of premises without consent, occasionally causing significant damage in the process, and distress to the person deprived...

Read more

Court of Appeal rules on 'defective' notices of retirement

The Court of Appeal has this week upheld the EAT’s decision in the case of R&R Plant (Peterborough) Ltd v Bailey (reported in our bulletin in May last year).

This case considered how much an employer was required to say ...

Read more

New Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012: how they may affect you

Following a European Commission ruling last year, followed by a lengthy consultation by the Health and Safety Executive, The Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 ('CAR 2012') come into force on 6 April this year.

Existing categorie...

Read more

Preparing Your Legacy: the PCT estate and related dispute resolution issues

The recent Department of Health (DoH) briefing on transferring the PCT estate shows that there is much to do, in a tight timescale, to regularise any undocumented business occupation of property, whether PCT interests are held as owner or as occup...

Read more

Commissioning Support Services: are you ready for checkpoint 2 and beyond?

Commissioning Support Services (CSS) are due to submit their outline business plans (OBP) for assurance and review on 31 March 2012 – known as checkpoint 2.

CCGs (clinical commissioning groups) will be free to choose the degree to wh...

Read more

Preparing your legacy - the PCT estate and related employment issues

As we advised our estates contacts across the NHS last week, the Department of Health has briefed PCTs on the timetable in relation to the transfer of the PCT estate to PropCo and provider NHS trusts and foundation trusts.

While the due di...

Read more

Preparing your legacy: the PCT estate

The Department of Health has briefed PCTs on the keenly awaited timetable in relation to the transfer of the PCT estate to PropCo and provider NHS trusts and foundation trusts.

As part of the preparation for transfer the Department require...

Read more

Court of Appeal dismisses age discrimination claim against Cumbria PCT

The Court of Appeal has handed down its decision in the case of Woodcock v Cumbria PCT. Upholding the decision of the EAT, the Court of Appeal has dismissed Mr Woodcock’s claim of redundancy-related age discrimination against the tr...

Read more

Rabone Equal rights to legal redress for bereaved relatives of informal and detained psychiatric patients

On 8th February 2012 the Supreme Court ruled that hospitals have an “operational” duty to protect the lives of “informal” psychiatric patients under Article 2 of the Human Rights Act (HRA).  This decision removes the l...

Read more

EAT confirms that termination agreements with GP practices can limit the risks for commissioners

In a recently released decision the Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT) has confirmed that a termination agreement entered into before a PCT stepped in to take over the practice of a suspended GP was effective to protect the PCT again...

Read more

Trust pay progression policy breaches Agenda for Change

In the case of Bent and others v Central Manchester University Hospitals NHS Trust, the Manchester Employment Tribunal has held that an NHS trust was not entitled to apply a local pay progression policy, which had the effect of deferring ...

Read more

Standard Contracting 2012 - 2013

David Flory’s recent letter to commissioners updates the guidance on the one year default contract duration and processes to be followed should commissioners wish to extend the Department of Health's NHS Standard Contract for 2012/2013 for u...

Read more

How to deal with restrictive covenants on land

These covenants can have a serious impact on the ability of any NHS organisation to sell surplus land, to carry out new developments, or to manage its estate.  For example, a covenant that only permits healthcare use is likely to have a drama...

Read more

Launching Capsticks Clinical Commissioning microsite

Capsticks is pleased to announce the go-live of its new microsite dedicated to clinical commissioning.  We know clinical commissioners need to focus on using their clinical expertise to develop patient centred, locally focused health services...

Read more

Suspending employees and involving the police in disciplinary matters

In a recent case the Court of Appeal has provided some useful guidance regarding the suspension of employees as part of disciplinary proceedings.  It has also made some interesting comments on the issue of reporting an employee to the police ...

Read more

English language competency amongst staff – are you doing enough?

NHS Employers has this week published guidance for NHS organisations in respect of their obligation to ensure that staff can communicate effectively in English.  This guidance has been introduced following public concerns which have been rais...

Read more

Announcing a new Constitution Development Tool for CCGs

Capsticks is pleased to introduce its Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) Constitution Development Tool.

Why we have developed this Tool

One of the key domains for the authorisation of each CCG is to be properly con...

Read more

Conditional break rights in leases: strict compliance and getting it right

At a time when estate rationalisation is still very much a key factor in cost saving measures and estates strategy, the recent case of Avocet Industrial Estates LLP v (1) Merol Limited (2) Tudor Rose International Limited [2011] EWHC 3422 (Ch) ser...

Read more

Estates and TUPE: addressing the risk of unexpected employee transfers

Health care providers and commissioners are increasingly aware of the risk of TUPE transfers when commissioning the delivery of services.  However, the potential application of TUPE in circumstances of property sales and leasing arrangements ...

Read more

Stabilising PMS contracts - the easy way

Now is the time for PCTs across England to act in order to ensure that all primary care contracts are in good shape for future transfer to the National Commissioning Board.

We are now in the ‘stabilise’ phase of primary care co...

Read more

Bedding in: the problem of bed blocking in the NHS

The current economic problems pose a number of challenges to the NHS.  One of the most significant is the rapidly growing problem for NHS trusts of bed blocking.  This is the practice where patients who have completed their treatment and...

Read more

Insolvent service providers and the NHS

The current economic climate has the unwelcome knock on effect of causing some providers to become insolvent. This has already resulted in some NHS bodies having to address issues when the providers they are contracting with cease to operate, and ...

Read more

Stocktake - step 2 starts today


On the 10th November 2011 David Flory wrote to SHA chief executives and PCT cluster chief executives setting out three key phases on the path to PCT dissolution: stocktake, stabilise and shift.

Stocktake - Have you finished s...

Read more

Redundancy and suitable alternative employment

If a redundant employee unreasonably refuses an offer of suitable alternative employment, that employee will lose the right to a redundancy payment. Whether or not a role amounts to suitable alternative employment depends on a number of factors, s...

Read more

DH latest announcements - Estates

After much uncertainty and speculation the Secretary of State for Health (“SOSH”) has announced the destination of the residual primary care trust estate.  In a ministerial statement presented to Parliament yesterday the Secretary...

Read more

Supreme Court rules on the limits to damages for the manner of dismissal

The Supreme Court has handed down its judgment today in the cases of Chesterfield Royal Hospital NHS Foundation Trust v Edwards and Botham v the Ministry of Defence which have been heard together. The Supreme Court has held that employees...

Read more

New provider landscape: first acquisition in South of England completed

On 9 January 2012 NHS South of England, Winchester and Eastleigh Healthcare NHS Trust and Basingstoke and North Hampshire NHS Foundation Trust completed a ground breaking transaction, establishing an enlarged and integrated Hampshire Hospitals Fou...

Read more

A Chief Coroner will be appointed after all

A High Court judge will now be appointed as the national Chief Coroner, to drive up the standards of inquests around the country and improve consistency of practice, which is good news for those healthcare organisations with difficult coroners.

Read more

Public sector worker given 6 year sentence in first Bribery Act prosecution

The first sentence involving the Bribery Act 2010 (“the Act”) has seen an administrative worker in the public sector being sentenced to 6 years' imprisonment after being found guilty of accepting bribes.

The sentence

Read more

Equal pay claims can benefit from six-year time limit

Must an equal pay claim be presented to an employment tribunal or can an employee choose to have it heard in the civil courts?  In a judgment delivered earlier this week, the Court of Appeal has ruled that employees can bring their claims in ...

Read more

Government sets out its proposals for employment law reforms

The Business Secretary, Vince Cable, on Wednesday set out the government’s proposals for a radical reform of UK employment laws, as the government published its response to the public consultation on “Resolving Workplace Disputes&rdquo...

Read more

Employees on sick leave must request annual leave

Capsticks has successfully defended a mental health trust against a claim from a former employee that she was entitled to accrued holiday pay relating to years in which she was absent on sick leave. Martin Hamilton, head of the employment departme...

Read more

PCT dissolution - planning for contract transfer

We expect primary care trusts ('PCTs') to be dissolved in 2013. Responsibility for the work currently carried out by PCTs will be transferred to other bodies. These new entities will include the National Commissioning Board and, of course, clinica...

Read more

Capsticks awarded best law firm at GP Awards

Capsticks has won the award for Law Firm of the Year at the General Practice Awards 2011. The award recognises the work Capsticks has done over the last 12 months to help NHS commissioners and GPs prepare for changes to the healthcare commissionin...

Read more

Any Qualified Provider: DH response to CCP recommendations

The Department of Health has responded this week to the Co-operation and Competition Panel’s (CCP’s) Report on Any Qualified Provider. The CCP’s report, published in July, reviewed the implementation of patient choice and made 9 ...

Read more

NHS Midlands and East, Hinchingbrooke Health Care NHS Trust and Circle complete landmark project

On Thursday 10 November 2011 NHS Midlands and East, Hinchingbrooke Health Care NHS Trust and Circle completed a ground breaking project, establishing the first statutory franchise agreement in England.

Capsticks was very pleased to advise ...

Read more

Second prosecution for corporate manslaughter

Cotswold Geotechnical Holdings ('GH') was convicted of an offence of corporate manslaughter on 15 February 2011 following the death of an employee in 2008. The Court of Appeal has since refused GH leave to appeal against various aspects of the con...

Read more

Public sector worker pleads guilty to Bribery Act offence

An administrative worker in the public sector has become the first person to be convicted under the Bribery Act 2010 ('the Act'), which came into force on 1 July 2011. This prosecution demonstrates that employees at all levels of an organisation c...

Read more

Government strategy for surplus land published

The Department of Health ('DoH') has published its strategy to accelerate the release of public sector land to help local communities and the NHS.

The strategy follows t...

Read more

Changing terms and conditions of employment

With the ever increasing financial pressures on healthcare bodies, many organisations are looking at whether savings can be made through adjusting the terms and conditions of their employees.

Wholesale changes to the terms and conditions o...

Read more

Government announces tribunal changes

The Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, has announced that, with effect from 6 April 2012, the qualifying period for bringing a claim of unfair dismissal will be increased from one to two years.  This is the latest development in the...

Read more

Challenges to procurement decisions: new time limits

On 1 October 2011, the Public Procurement (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2011 will come into force ('the 2011 Regulations'). The 2011 Regulations will amend the Public Contracts Regulations 2006 and change the general time frame for bringi...

Read more

Capsticks awarded best legal team in healthcare sector

Capsticks has won the award for best legal team at the 2011 Independent Healthcare Association awards. The IHA awards is one of the main annual events for the private healthcare industry.

The award was made as a result of the growth, varie...

Read more

Applying TUPE where services differ post-transfer

The EAT (Employment Appeal Tribunal) has recently provided useful guidance on the correct interpretation of TUPE where services provided post-transfer differ from services before the change of provider.

In Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Tr...

Read more

DH publishes arrangements for SHA clustering

The Department of Health has published a briefing note on the arrangements for SHA clustering. Contact details for further enquiries are given at the end of this article.

Key features are:

SHA clusters will come into effect on 3 Oc...

Read more

Fairness of dismissal for refusing to accept a pay cut

In the recent case of Garside and Laycock Ltd v Booth, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has considered the question of whether an employer’s dismissal of an employee for failing to accept a reduction in pay...

Read more

Supreme Court confirms no automatic right to legal representation at disciplinary hearing

The case of G v the Governors of X School ('G v X') concerned a teaching assistant, G, who was alleged to have committed an act of sexual misconduct with a 15 year old pupil. This led to disciplinary action against G ...

Read more

High Court confirms PCTs are able to terminate PMS agreements on 6 months notice

The High Court has confirmed that primary care trusts are entitled to terminate Personal Medical Services agreements on 6 months’ notice pursuant to the National Health Service (Personal Medical Services agreements)...

Read more

Employer liable for harassment by third party

The case of Sheffield City Council v Norouzi involves a claim of race discrimination and harassment brought by an Iranian employee working as a resident social worker in a children’s care home.

One of the children in the care home re...

Read more

Provisional damages and variable periodical payments: the High Court provides guidance

The risk of a syrinx, a cavity which develops within the spinal cord which can become filled with fluid and cause further significant disability, is a common feature of spinal injury claims and often forms the basis for a request that provisional ...

Read more

Draft Defamation Bill: key points

The Ministry of Justice has published a draft Defamation Bill and consultation. The draft Bill is intended to update and simplify the law of defamation, which is currently drawn from statutes and extensive case law. The key points which could be r...

Read more

Retirement notices: case causes concern

The recent case of Bailey v R&R Plant has raised concerns for employers as it suggests that many notices of retirement which were issued prior to the abolition of the statutory retirement procedure in April this year may be procedurally defect...

Read more

Sharon Shoesmith’s dismissal following Baby P case unlawful

Sharon Shoesmith was the Director of Children’s Services for Haringey Council at the time of the Baby P tragedy. Following an urgent OFSTED inspection and report, the Secretary of State Ed Balls removed Ms Shoesmith from her office as Direct...

Read more

7/7 bombings inquest verdict

The 7th July London Bombings inquest verdict and recommendations were announced on 6th May. Rob Wilson, a partner in Capsticks' inquest team has been advising the London Ambulance Service at the inquest which was one of the biggest to take pl...

Read more

Personally named respondents in discrimination cases

When employees bring a discrimination case it is not uncommon for them to name, in addition to the employer, their line manager and/or other individuals as personally named Respondents. This is always a matter of concern for those named. The Emplo...

Read more

Equity and Excellence – Liberating the NHS

The Health and Social Care Act 2012

After more than 1,000 amendments, the Health and Social Care Bill has now received Royal assent.

The themes of organisational change; choice and competition; improving quality an...

Read more